Facing the Future: A Thought-Provoking Think-In on Facial Recognition Technology at Beta Festival
On 7 November, ADAPT held a #DiscussAI Think-In event, Facing the Future: Let’s Talk Facial Recognition Technology, as part of this year’s Beta Festival. Co-organised by Dr Ciara Bracken-Roche and Dr Emma Clarke, the Think-In brought together diverse voices for an engaging and timely discussion on the potential impacts of facial recognition technology (FRT) in Irish policing.
With the Government’s current plans to implement FRT in law enforcement, the event provided a valuable platform for the public to critically examine the technology’s implications. The conversation began with expert insights from dkg (Daniel Kahn Gillmor), Senior Staff Technologist with the ACLU’s Speech, Privacy and Technology Project, and Olga Cronin, Senior Policy Officer at the Irish Council for Civil Liberties (ICCL). Both speakers highlighted the arguments for and against FRT on safety, privacy, freedom and civil rights, setting the stage for a balanced debate on this complex issue.
Following the initial presentations, participants divided into small groups to discuss a scenario focusing on FRT’s role in public safety: Would we support using FRT to identify a vandal after car damage or track a person involved in an unintentional hit-and-run? This scenario encouraged deliberation on the accuracy of FRT systems, privacy implications and the fairness of deploying it in justice systems. From locating missing persons to possible misidentifications, the potential benefits and risks of FRT were discussed.
Participants also had the opportunity to experience Calculating Empires, a compelling research visualisation by Kate Crawford and Vladan Joler. This large-scale installation, on display at The Digital Hub as part of Beta Festival, traces the evolution of technology and social structures over the last five centuries. Calculating Empires invites viewers to contemplate the historical, economic and ethical dimensions underpinning modern technological systems, making it an essential piece in the festival lineup.
The Think-In highlighted the complexities and societal stakes involved in FRT’s integration into policing and underscored the public’s role in having their say on technology policies.
Beta Festival runs until 17 November 2024.
